Chapter 4: M or X

"The party is at Thad's house - really?" Blaine turned away from the body size mirror in his room and looked at his brother. Sebastian was carelessly spread out on Blaine's gray and maroon bedding and holding a life and science magazine.

"That's what David told me. Apparently everyone is pretty pissed about it." Sebastian was holding the magazine up to his nose, but his eyes stayed focused above the brim of the booklet. It was difficult to concentrate on words when Blaine was only wearing a white fitted t-shirt and tight black underwear.

"What happened?" Blaine frowned. If there was one thing Blaine did not want to do, it was to subject himself to the company of Thad Hawthorne.

Thad Hawthorne is the same age as Blaine with dark brown hair, brushy eyebrows and as of last year Blaine's ideal boy-toy. Thad was (and still is) in the closet, (still) desperate for the approval his parent's never gave him, and he was (and still is) curious, willing and excited for Blaine topracticeon him. It all went wrong when Thad realized he and Blaine were not in an exclusive relationship. After their two weeks of near constant intercourse Thad went from in love to angry, clingy and then obsessed with everything relating to Blaine.

Thad would write and leave love notes in places he knew Blaine would find them. He redid his dorm to resemble Blaine's. For the most part Blaine was lenient with Thad's obsessions. Blaine did not (and does not) complain when Thad writes about him in his blog - detailing their intimate and non-intimate times together. It is safe to say that no one reads the blog because most people still believe Thad is straight. Even if someone did find and read it, it was practically free sex advertisement for himself. What Blaine could not ignore was Thad scaring off prospective conquests.

Blaine grabbed his favorite red pants and stepped into them. The pants fit perfectly around his legs and butt. According to Sebastian he knew the outfit made him looked like 'walking sex.'

"From what I was told," giving up his attempt to finish the article Sebastian tossed the magazine on the night stand and drummed his fingers on his shirt covered abs. "Apparently Jeff doesn't understand that saying 'party' out loud and in front a faculty member tends to raise suspicion. Now that the party has been compromised it needed to be translocate. Thad offered his parent's house. I guess his parents are in Naples."

Blaine pulled the white shirt over his head, flexing his bare back to Sebastian when he retrieved his black shirt from the wardrobe.

"I'd rather they just cancel the party. Thad probably planned the whole thing," Blaine slid into the shirt and grabbed his favorite red bowtie. "He is probably hoping that if he hosts a party then he may make a friend or two. If he wants to make friends, then he should stop stalking people and calling them at odd hours." Happy with the bowtie, Blaine walked to his bathroom and grabbed a bottle of hair gel. "Did I ever tell you about the time he text me every two minutes for three hours? He was drunk and feeling stressed about end of the year exams. He wanted me to come over and cheer him up. He is pathetic." Blaine finished adding gel to his hair.

"If you don't want to go, then why are you going?" Sebastian smile. Thad was one Sebastian's favorite topic to discuss with Blaine. "Are you trying to impress him? I see the way he looks at you and I see how you love the ego boost. Why don't you just sleep with him again? I bet his faithful blog reader," Sebastian raised his hand to signal himself as the lone reader, "Would appreciate new material." Sebastian laughed and the younger glared daggers. "There are only so many times I can read about your Napoleon complex and not get curious. Is he referring to your short height or is something else short?" Sebastian voice held false thoughtfulness and his smirk was unashamed.

Blaine stomped out of the bathroom and towards his dresser where he kept his silver watch. "I cannot believe I was dumb enough to sleep with that moron last year. I told him up front I just wanted someone to fool around with. The next thing I know he thinks we are dating, even though he is still in the closet. Besides it's not like we even know anything about the other. We both knew the other was clean and attractive. What else did he need to know at the time? We slept together off and on for two weeks. What was he thinking?"

"Slept together? More like fucked liked rabbits. I don't know what you two did.... Wait no, I read his blog so actually I do know what you two did. He certainly liked it and based on Thad's limp and your smirk you enjoyed it too."

"I was getting laid it was difficult not to be happy at the time. I only wish I could say it wasn't with Thad. It's embarrassing now." Blaine rolled his eyes and frowned. "Although I will admit he has a very talented mouth."

"Wait! You said you guys fucked for two weeks. I thought it was just one? The week before fall break....shit, you were with him for fall break. I knew you lied about going to Hartford to visit Yale." Sebastian set up quickly.

Blaine laughed. "You just now realize that. I thought you were the smart one,Mr. Future Valedictorian." Blaine purred. With a normal voice Blaine continued, "It's what mom and dad wanted to hear and I wanted to get laid. Who cares what lie I concocted to get it?"

"You mean con-cocked." Sebastian corrected.

"Laugh all you want. The joke is on me anyway. I have to live with the fact that I slept with Thad." Blaine's shoulders shuttered at the recollection. Blaine turned his back to the mirror and admired his own body.

"Is that why you don't want to go to Thad's house? Does it have too many memories of you two fooling around? Which rooms did you do it in? Oh man, Thad's house is going to be like a mystery museum." Sebastian moved his body so he was setting on his feet. "Which rooms did you and Thad fuck in, and how did you do it? Those will be the questions of the tonight! I should leave an anonymous comment on Thad's blog and encourage that he make a game out of it." The older brother's eyes glimmered with excitement. "Now, about new material..."

"I will never touch Thad again."

"What if Thad touches you instead?"

"I would have to be blind to allow that to happen. Don't you need to get ready?" Blaine asked, pleased with his own appearance. He was wearing a red bowtie that whispered 'come to me', a tight black button shirt that purred 'touch me', and red hot pants that screamed 'fuck me.'

Sebastian clearly heard the subtle message. "Nice outfit, Blaine."

Blaine winked.

"Yeah, let's migrate to my room. I need to get ready too."

"Any word on who your roommate is?" Blaine laughed. The idea of having a roommate still sounded horrible.

"Yeah, Wes texted me earlier, I will be bunking with some new student. He is a year younger than me, but I guess that was how it worked out. His name is Kevin, Kyle, Kit or something like that. I don't really care. Wes said mentioned that he is Nick's cousin." Sebastian shrugged. "Let me check him out before I make my decision to keep him or not."

"Nick's cousin?"

"I know, cousin. Sounds hot," Sebastian smirked.

...

For Sebastian, the party had the three essentials for a good time. There was cold alcohol, hot guys, and one very sexually flustered younger brother. Blaine on the other hand was miserable. He was in a paradise of hot guys who were too horny to remember if they were straight or not, but instead of devouring open season prey, he was victim to a parasite called Thad Hawthorne.

For different reasons than Blaine's, the rest of the party was unhappy to. The sudden change of location deterred many girls from coming, and the fact that the party was at Thad's house did not help matters. Most of the guys did not see reason to stay.

"No don't go." Thad chased after Blaine and a number of other guys who wanted to leave. "The party just started. We're here to have fun."

"You had good intentions, but this isn't working out." Nick softened his voice. Nick was the only boy at the party who did not enjoy the taste or effects of alcohol.

"Jeff!" Thad cried and ran up to the blond who was grabbing his shoes next to the front door. "How can I fix this party?"

"I know how you can fix it." Sebastian pulled his hands from his pockets and walked towards the crying boy. Thad froze and ran to Sebastian. "If you want people stay you need to offer them some entertainment. I suppose a game. May I recommend a party game Blaine and I invented, it's called M or X." Sebastian smiled when Thad widened his eyes.

"What is M or X?" Hunter asked, holding the door handle and ready to leave.

M or X was not so much a game the brothers invented, but more of a modification to the classic party game truth or dare. Only in this game, participants did not share fluffy truths, but instead players revealed M rated true story. Dares included X rated challenges. It was a simple game Blaine and Sebastian started when they wanted to loosen up their straight friends.

"I'm not nearly drunk enough for that." Someone whined and opened the door and left. A number of boys followed.

"Let's make it a Warbler bonding experience." Sebastian offered. None of the Warbler's would be able to deny a Warbler get-together.

"That's sounds prefect." Thad jumped on his toes, happy that some people, namely Blaine, would be staying. "Sebastian, you're a good friend."

Two hours and countless drinks later twelve drunk, two mildly tipsy and one sober boy formed a circle in the Hawthorne living room.

"Blaine," Sebastian leaned into his brother. "Just tell me one story that happened in this mystery museum." Blaine frowned and pushed Sebastian away from him. "Did you fuck Thad in the library with a candlestick? Oops wrong game." Sebastian smirked, purposefully referencing to the board game 'Clue.'

"I want to begin the game." Blaine raised his hand and took a sip of the same drink he was holding all night. He was an ugly drunk and needed to contain himself.

"That's the spirit Blaine." Thad beamed and shinned his bedroom eyes. "I choose X."

"No Thad. My question is directed to Jeff." The blond eyes bulged open, clearly not ready to be the first to go in the game. "Okay Jeff, M or X?"

"You know what? I screwed up tonight. Give me a big ol' X." Jeff boldly answered.

Blaine was many things. If there was one thing Blaine believed himself to be it was a good friend, not that it was always seemed that way. "Jeff, I want you to give Nick a lap dance." The brown haired boy setting in the corner drinking water froze when Blaine said his name. "Feel free to shed some of your clothing while you're at it." Blaine added well aware of Nick's lack of comfort.

Nick came out of the closet the same time Blaine did. He was scared about coming out, considering his family was not as accepting as the Andersons. It was after that Blaine adopted Nick as his friend and made it his mission to help Nick get laid. Blaine and Nick's friendship hit a rough patch over summer break when Blaine convinced Nick lose his virginity to Sebastian. Blaine told Nick that sex would boost his confidence. The following morning when Nick cried and cursed Blaine. Blaine promised himself that he would restore this friendship by helping Nick get intimate with the one person he has been crushing over with since freshmen year: female-loving Jeff Sterling.

Jeff jumped off of the chair he was seating on and drunkenly stumbled towards Nick. Nick forgot how to talk, "I-i-it is-s-s okay." Jeff undone his top shirt button, "J-J-Jeff, you don't have to." A second button was popped open, "H-h-how a-a-about we p-p-pretend this-s-s happened?" The sound of the third button coming undone echoed against the sound of Nick's racing heart.

"Not allowed!" Blaine shouted.

Of course no one was forced to play along with the game. Anyone was allowed to leave when they wanted to. However Nick's desire for Jeff's to remain dressed faded once music started and Jeff crawled onto his lap dressed in nothing but black underwear.

"Work it!" Sebastian shouted against the music. Jeff moved his body so that he was now straddling Nick's body and he started to frantically rock his hips into Nick's.

"Bite his ears!" Blaine yelled. After Sebastian slept with Nick, Sebastian told Blaine that Nick's weak spot was his ears.

Jeff brought his mouth up to Nick's left ear and attentively bit down.

The dance continued until the song stop. Thankfully for Nick, all of the guys, including Jeff, were too drunk to notice the action taking place in his pants. Nobody noticed part from Blaine and Sebastian who were only mildly drunk.

"Well done Jeff." Blaine cheered and offered Nick thumbs up. "Did you enjoy that Nick?" Blaine asked, trying to measure if Nick forgave him or not.

Blaine shrugged his shoulders when Nick ignored him. He later rolled his eyes when Nick pick up his jacket and race from the room crying."He'll thank me later."Blaine assured himself.

"That was hot Jeff." Sebastian smirked. Drinking in the rare sight of Jeff's tone abs. Jeff just laughed and brushed his bangs from his eyes. "Okay hottie," Sebastian winked. "It's your turn to challenge someone."

"Why is Jeff not wearing pants?" Wes sleepily asked from asleep on the couch. "Did I miss something?" The boy's confusion went ignored.

"Okay, hottie," Without getting dressed Jeff returned to the game. "Sebastian I want you to choose M."

Sebastian laughed, "I don't get to choose."

Jeff bit his lips in effort to prevent himself from laughing. "I have a question and I want agoodanswer." Jeff stumbled towards Sebastian and fell between the brothers. "Have you ever kissed or slept with Blaine? You guys don't act like brothers."

Blaine and Sebastian laughed at the same time. Jeff was too cute, blond, drunk and practically naked. The fact that he was sandwich between them did not go unnoticed by either brother.

Sebastian draped his arm around Jeff, "I have never kissed or slept with Blaine, but that doesn't mean I haven't tried or turn him down more than once."

"But you'rebrothers!"

Sebastian brushed his other hands over Jeff's bare knees. "The heart wants what the heart wants. Do you know what I mean?" Sebastian pulled Jeff closer to his body.

"Okay, Blaine it's your turn. What will it be, M or X?" Sebastian asked. His arms wrapped around Jeff, who may or may not have been passed out.

"We want X." Thad slurred next to the fireplace. "Come on, please Blaine. Don't you remember that one time we fooled around on the pool table in the basement? You really liked it. Let's do it again."

"You did want on the pool table." Wes was now on the floor and rubbing his head.

"It's nothing Wes. Sebastian wants Blaine and me to play a game."

Sebastian ignored Thad, Wes, and the blond curled in his arms. "Blaine, I want you to play a trust game."

Blaine raised his eye brows. "Don't I get a choice?"

"No. You have to trust me for this game to work. Do you trust me?"

"Sure." Blaine answered and Sebastian smiled.

Sebastian gingerly rolled Jeff to his side and Blaine helped Wes back to the couch. All of the other boys were already asleep. Thad however watched the brothers, hoping that he would get something to do.

Once the brothers were assure that no one would miss them besides Thad, they sunk out of the living room.

The lightening in the living room was darker than that of the rest of the house; and the bright lights were painful on their eyes.

"So, I learned one mystery about this place. You fucked Thad on a pool table. Let me say, that sounds hot."

"Shut up." Blaine growled, "Where are we going anyway?"

"Where is Thad's room? There is something I really want to do in there." As much as Blaine hated to admit it, he remembered exactly where Thad's room was.

The Hawthorne house was not as large as the Anderson's home, but it was still a fair sized residence. The floors were made of wood and the ceiling were tall. Thad's room was easy to recognize. It looked like a typically boy room with a half-dressed girl on the wall and a masculine odor in the air.

"Please tell me I'm correct." Sebastian brushed past Blaine and opened Thad's closet. "I knew it." The older brother reached into the closet and pulled out a black shiny suitcase. "I knew Thad would have a box of goodies." Sebastian angled the suitcase away from Blaine and ordered the younger boy to lie down.

"We're going to play a trust game. I want you to lie down and allow me to put a few things on you. After which you can decide whether this game is fun or not."

Blaine's eyes darkened and he moved his body towards the bed. At this point in time either brother knew who was in control or how far things would go.

"Very good," Sebastian encouraged. "Now raise your hands." Blaine stared into Sebastian's dark eyes and did as he was told. Sebastian handcuffed Blaine to the bed. "Good boy, now close your eyes." The older brother secured a blindfold over the younger eyes. "Very good," Sebastian moved off the bed and grabbed something else from the black box. "I want you to focus on touch and not the other senses. I'm going to cover your ears now. If at any point you don't want to play any more than just say 'stop.' Other than that try not to talk," the older boy instructed.

"Okay," Blaine's voiced waved. They have never gone this far before. Apart of Blaine was excited, but the other half was unsure.

"I forgot something. I'll be right back." Blaine was lost of words when he felt cool plastic headphones cover his ears. "I won't be gone long."

Blaine may have waited five minutes or five hours before he felt a dip in the bed. Two long legs straddle him and a pair of lips latch onto his neck. The lips were hunger and the legs stronger then he imagined, but it felt too good to argue against. The sucking was painfully alluring and it matched perfectly in strength and rate of the thrusting hips. Blaine wanted more. He needed more. He had always been attracted to Sebastian, but he never believed that they would make it this far. Yes, they would touch each other in places they should not, but never once have they actually kissed or allowed their dry humping to be this rapid or for this long. Blaine bucked his legs up and tried to free his hands. He wanted wrapped in fingers in Sebastian's hair. Cool air caked over Blaine's abs as a pair a hands unbutton his shirt. The lips journeyed down Blaine's column neck and towards his nipples. Blaine moaned when he felt a tongue tease his right nipple. Before Blaine had a chance to get bored with the nipple play, the same pair of hands started to undo and unzip his red "fuck me" pants. Blaine lifted his hips and his pants were lowered.

It took every ounce of Blaine's being not to scream from pleasure when a warm mouth engulfed his sex. So began a very enthusiastic blow job.

...

Fifteen minutes earlier...

Sebastian slid the headphones around Blaine's ears and picked himself off the bed.

The living room did not look any different than how he left it. Jeff was moaning and squirming where Sebastian left him, Wes was sleeping on the couch, and everyone else was sleeping on the floor. Meanwhile Thad sat looking sad and lonely.

"Thad." Sebastian called from the doorway.

Thad jumped from his chair and ran to Sebastian. "Yeah?"

"Do you still want to play a game?" Sebastian did not wait for a reply. "Blaine's waiting for you. For this game, just give him a good blow job, nothing more. If he changes his mind and tells you to stop, then stop." Thad's eyes lit up. "I mean it. If I hear him screaming for you to stop and you don't, then youwillregret it."

Thad frantically shook his head. "I won't mess this up and I would never hurt Blaine like that." Thad tried not to shout, "I'll treat him right. Thank you so much Sebastian for giving me another chance with him. Once he sees how good I can make him feel, he'll want to take me back."

"Also, don't remove his cuffs, blindfolds or headphones. Once he is done he will probably fall asleep and just leave him like that. I'll take it from there."

"Thank you so much Sebastian. You are a great friend." Thad hugged Sebastian before scurrying to his bedroom.

Jeff moaned from the couch, the tent in his pants did not go unnoticed. "Come on Jeff." Sebastian put his hands on the blond boy's bare skin. "Let's see if we can find a room - I can help you with those dreams you're having."