"I'm not sure." Tina said.

"We think Blaine might be missing." Mike explained.

"Missing?" Quinn said, a bit shocked.

"Did I just hear that curly has gone missing?" Santana asked as she walked over, holding Brittany's hand.

"Yeah, he left a while ago and never came back." Mike said.

"And now Kurt's running around the beach like a chicken with his head cut off." Puck added.

"Maybe he went back to the ocean to live with his fish family." Brittany suggested.

"Will you drop the whole merman thing? Blaine is not a fish." Puck said with a groan.

"Hey, mohawk, back off." Santana spat out.

"Guys! We don't have time for this, we should be helping Kurt find Blaine."

"Mike's right, let's help Kurt look." Tina said.

"Leave it to the mute to go missing and ruin the whole trip." Santana mumbled as she walked past Burt.

"What is going on around here?" Burt asked Finn. "Did I just hear that Blaine's missing?"

Finn bit his lip. "Something like that."

"Where's Kurt?"

"He ran towards the docks, he's trying to find him."

"I told you kids you're not suppose to go over there..." Burt said before going after Kurt, Finn quickly following after him.

...............................................................................................................................................................................................................

"Blaine!" Kurt shouted, starting to really panic. Where was he? Why wasn't he answering? What if the sea witch had already come and taken him away? What if she hurt him? What if he never saw him again?

When he finally spotted Blaine under the dock, he let out a sigh of relief before racing over to him. "There you are, I was so worried about you, I've been looking for you everywhere, why did you wander off like that?" he asked as he pulled Blaine into a tight hug.

"It's okay, guys! Kurt found him!" Kurt heard Mike yell from behind him.

"Come on, let's go, we need to get you as far away from here as we can." Kurt said, pulling on Blaine's arm, but Blaine didn't move. "Blaine?" he asked, suddenly growing worried when he noticed the pained look on Blaine's face.

"Blaine, are you okay?" He continued, but Blaine wasn't responding at all. As he opened his mouth to ask what was wrong, Blaine fell to the floor, Kurt quickly kneeling down next to him and gasping when he realized what was happening.

Blaine's legs were green, the exact same shade his fin had been before he'd gotten legs.

He was too late.

Blaine wrapped his arms around his stomach in pain and his head fell forward as Kurt put his hands on his shoulders. He had no idea what to do, it was obvious that the transformation back to a merman was hurting Blaine, he just didn't know what to do to stop it. He opened his mouth to say something but was cut off by the most evil, horrid, laughter he'd ever heard in his life. The sound would put any movie villain to shame, and for the first time in his life, he saw Blaine looking absolutely terrified.

He followed Blaine's gaze to the ocean, watching as the water swirled and spiraled out of control, the sky getting dark as the wind blew so harshly Kurt honestly thought he might fall over. He didn't even bother glancing back to see the confused and shocked reactions from his fellow Glee Club members who had followed him here.

He wouldn't have time to explain to them what was happening anyway.

Suddenly, the scariest creature he had ever seen which could only be described as something from a horror film popped above the water, making her way towards Blaine.

Blaine was right, she did look like a zombie.

Before he could move, she grabbed Blaine, yanking him towards the water as she laughed evilly and shrieked the words times up in the creepiest voice he'd ever heard.

"No!" He shouted, diving towards Blaine as quickly as he could, grabbing Blaine's hand and attempting to pull him back to the sand but Blaine's hand slipped out of his. He dove for him a second time, but he missed him just as he was pulled under.

"No, no! Blaine!" He screamed even louder than before, tears burning his eyes. He couldn't let this happen. Blaine couldn't leave him like this. Blaine hadn't even turned back into a merman completely yet... what if he couldn't breathe under water... what if he died?

"Blaine!" He yelled one last time as the large waves knocked him over.

Blaine was gone.

He wouldn't let it end this way, he refused to.

He wouldn't lose Blaine so easily, he wouldn't allow him to slip through his grasp just like that.

So he ran, just ran, as fast as he could towards the water, until he felt someone grab his arm.

"Where the hell do you think you're going?"

"He hasn't changed back completely, dad, I have to save him, what if he drowns?"

"What do you mean changed back completely? Kurt, what the hell is going on?"

Kurt took that moment to glance back at the shocked faces of everyone in New Directions, as well as his own father.

"Blaine's a merman." He said softly, tears running down his face.

"Wait a minute... you mean Brittany was right?" Puck asked loudly, shock evident on his face.

"Maybe you'll listen to me next time a magical creature joins our glee club." Brittany said with a shrug.

Kurt sighed before continuing.

"Blaine's a merman I met last time I was here, he didn't want me to leave, so he traded away his voice so that he could come with me... I've been lying to all of you about who Blaine really is. But I had a good reason... would you have believed me if I told you the truth?"

Kurt looked back and forth between everyone before watching as Puck stepped forward. "You're never going to be able to get him if you just dive in."

"I can't just let him go..."

"I know, that's why we're going to need a boat."

This wasn't over yet.