"Wait," Blaine started connecting everything in his mind. Shit it was all making sense. "Who is Eli?" Blaine asked, even though he was pretty sure he knew the answer…

"Kurt's boyfriend of 14 months." Rachel said almost flinching at the way Blaine's face fell instantly at her words.

"Oh shit." Blaine stood. "Rachel take me to your house, I have to talk to Kurt." Sure he didn't know Rachel but this problem just went from bad to really fucking bad in a matter of just a few words. Kurt had a boyfriend. Blaine walked toward the door, Rachel rushed out after him. Mike stood but didn't follow.

Rachel grabbed Blaine's arm trying to stop him. "Blaine stop." He didn't, he just ignored her words. "Blaine, he isn't going to want to talk to you." Blaine stopped at those words.

Rachel was right; Blaine turned around and faced her. Giving up so easy; he barely knew Kurt, but he would feel guilty until he talked to him, said he was sorry. He knew that in order to make this right he had to explain to Kurt that he had never meant to hurt him.

Two weeks had went by and Kurt was still worried, sad, upset, and pissed off mostly at himself though; it was Blaine's fault too, but he couldn't push himself to Blame Blaine cause he had no idea about the fact that Kurt was cheating on his boyfriend, plus he really didn't know Blaine that well...Which hurt worse cause of the fact that not only did he cheat on Eli but he did it with a guy he barely knew.

Kurt sat on the floor at his house with a phone in his hand. Mercedes sat across from him; she looked at Kurt with concern in her eyes.

"Kurt, you have to tell him sometime, the longer you wait the worse it will be." Mercedes stated. Kurt knew her words were true, but he couldn't bring himself to tell Eli about what had happened. He didn't want to hurt him.

"Mercedes…I can't tell him. I can't do it. I just can't hurt him." Kurt looked down at the phone in hand.

"Kurt, if you don't I will." Mercedes glared.

"Ok, ok, you're right." Kurt hesitated as he looked at the phone. He pressed the 'call' button as he slowly lifted the phone to his ear…

"Hello?" Eli's voice answered.

Kurt tried to say something, anything. Nothing happened he couldn't get his voice to work. Why did this have to be so difficult?

"Hello? Kurt?" Eli's voice rang out again. Kurt couldn't speak he quickly hung up, looking at Mercedes with a scared look on his face.

"What the fuck was that?" Mercedes raised her voice at Kurt.

"I don't know I choked!" Kurt panicked. Just as he said this, his phone rang. "Oh no, it's Eli." Before Kurt could grab the phone from the ground, Mercedes had taken it in her grasp and held it to her ear.

"Hello, Eli." Mercedes said calmly as she glared at Kurt. Mercedes handed Kurt the phone, "He wants to talk to you…"

Kurt didn't take it, shaking his head franticly. "No, Mercedes…Tell him I'm not here." Kurt tried whispering quietly to her in a panic.

"No." Mercedes said bluntly. "Grow some balls." She whispered at him as she held the phone out to Kurt, he reluctantly took it.

"H-hello?" Kurt stuttered.

"Kurt what's up? Is something wrong?" Eli spoke concerned on the other line. Kurt looked up at Mercedes trying to get an answer from her; she just shrugged giving him a forceful look.

"No, I was just- uh- I was just thinking of you…That's all." Kurt tried to keep his voice steady. Mercedes gave him a disappointed glance.

Mercedes mouthed the words "Grow some balls."

"Kurt we've been together for a year and two months. I know something is wrong, do you want to talk about it over coffee?" Eli's words were calm and sweet.

Kurt hesitated but gave in, "Yeah, ok." Kurt sighed.

"Alright I'll pick you up in ten minutes we can go to the coffee shop by my house, alright?" Eli said.

Kurt froze. Blaine worked there. What if he was working today? "Um-" Kurt thought, "Ok." He silently prayed that Blaine wasn't working today. Kurt didn't want to hurt Eli. He knew he would have to tell him sooner or later. Kurt had hung up the phone, now looking at Mercedes.

Blaine walked into the coffee shop in hopes that Kurt would stop by. It had been two weeks since the 'club incident' and Blaine still felt guilty, and Kurt hadn't even stopped by once. Mike was telling him to let it go, and forget about that night, it was a simple mistake, no big deal. Rachel was telling him to give Kurt space to wait for Kurt to come to him, but he wasn't; he never showed up to the coffee shop anymore and Blaine had to say something to him, anything, I'm sorry? I was drunk? You were drunk? It wasn't your fault. Blaine didn't know what he would say, but he had to say something to him to make this right and salvage any possible chance at gaining Kurt's forgiveness. How did it come down to this? From Blaine wanting to simply ask for Kurt's number; to a drunken night at the club full of regrets and guilt. He barely knew Kurt, yet he felt so bad about that night that it was starting to make him feel sick.

Blaine walked behind the serving counter. The coffee shop was slightly busy, Blaine scanned the shop for Kurt, but instead he saw Sebastian smirking at him from across the room. Blaine looked away, but it was too late he had already locked eyes with the bastard that is his ex, Sebastian.

Sebastian made his way to the counter; Blaine crossed his arms looking at Sebastian with an unwelcoming glare in attempts to tell him he was not in the mood. The taller boy didn't seem to care as he made his way to the counter.

"Hey Killer." Sebastian stood looking at Blaine his 'bitch face' turning into a 'curious bitch face.'

Blaine held his hand up to stop Sebastian from saying anything more…"Don't" he spoke quietly, trying to not sound vulnerable.

"Aw, what's wrong babe?" Sebastian said leaning over the counter getting closer to Blaine. Blaine stepped back.

"Don't call me that." Blaine said simply turning away and pretending to be busy cleaning something.

Sebastian walked around the counter giving Blaine a look that made his stomach twist, and not in a good way.

Blaine ignored his question, knowing that he knew the answer already. "You can't be back here." Blaine simply stated still pretending to clean random things that actually didn't need cleaning at all.

Sebastian didn't say anything. Blaine sighed; frustrated as he felt Sebastian's hands on his hips. Blaine turned sharply in attempt to stop Sebastian when he came face to face with the taller boy. Trying to look anywhere but in his eyes. He then saw Kurt walking into the shop with a tall, blond, it must be Eli. It had to be right? Without thinking Blaine ducked behind the counter dragging Sebastian down with him.

"Blaine you could've just said you wanted me right now-" Sebastian spoke just before Blaine's hand came up to cover his mouth.

"Shut up, Sebastian." Blaine whispered in a slight panic, he had to think quickly. What was he going to do? He wanted to talk to Kurt, but he was pretty sure that was Eli if Kurt holding hands with him was any indication. Blaine hoped to God that they for some reason wouldn't come up to the serving counter. He pressed his ear to the counter listening to them.

Sebastian slowly took Blaine's hand off of his mouth and peeked over the counter, just before Blaine pulled him back down next to him. "Oh- it's that guy you were flirting with a few weeks ago, he's with a guy." Sebastian peeked over the counter again. "There just sitting there, looks serious." He shrugged scooting closer to Blaine as they sat with their backs against the counter.

"Shut up." Blaine whispered again, he listened to Kurt and Eli's conversation.

"Eli, I need to tell you something…" Kurt said, he paused.

"Ok, baby, you can tell me anything." Eli's voice was calm, even though Kurt seemed to be anything but calm.

Kurt sighed "Well, I uh- went to Provocateur, and I- I had a little to drink. Then I danced with another guy." Kurt paused.

"That's it?" Eli sounded relieved. "Kurt, you worried me for a second."

Blaine was internally freaking out, well maybe not just internally if Sebastian's stare had any indication. Blaine sighed for a moment, just before he heard Kurt speak again…

"Well-" Kurt stopped himself. "I'm going to get myself something to drink." Kurt sounded disappointed with himself for not telling the whole truth. Blaine heard his footsteps approach the counter. Still sitting, wide-eyed and worried, freaking out in his mind. What now?

Sebastian smirked as Kurt swiftly hit the attention bell on the counter. Blaine sat frozen. He thought facing Kurt would be easier than this, but there he sat, literally hiding.

Kurt rang the bell again. Blaine had no clue what to do, his heart was beating fast, why was he freaking out so much?

"You owe me." Sebastian whispered in his ear as he stood. "Can I help you?" Sebastian spoke as he smiled at Kurt. Blaine sat now not in panic but slightly in shock. Kurt went to speak but before he could speak Zoe walked out from the kitchen stopping in confusion as she approached the situation…

"Sebastian, I know you hang around here a lot, but that doesn't give you the right to serve people, and Blaine, why are you on the ground" Zoe spoke in a confused but not angry tone.

Blaine slowly pulled himself off the floor. He made quick eye contact with Kurt before looking down, not sure what to say.

"You've got to be kidding me." Kurt said under his breath. "You know what- I'm just going to leave…" Kurt then turned and walked over to Eli, grabbing Eli's arm and walking quickly out of the shop.

"Would you mind telling me what that was about?" Zoe said slightly confused and annoyed as she crossed her arms and looked at Blaine shifting awkwardly.

Blaine felt Sebastian's gaze fall on him as well. He continued to shift before sighing and explaining himself…

"I went to the club a few nights ago..." Blaine hesitated, "I drank a little more than I should have and…Well, we um-"

"Messed around?" Sebastian finished his sentence with a smirk. Blaine glared in his direction then nodded.

Zoe put her hand on Blaine's shoulder as if to comfort him. "Well, Blaine everybody has drunken mistakes every now and then, I don't see the-"

"The problem is, he is dating another guy." Blaine said. Sebastian and Zoe stared at him with wide eyes.

"Wow, Anderson, was not expecting that, especially from you." Sebastian said as he sat on the serving counter.

"Blaine!" Zoe said more serious sounding than Sebastian had, "You can't just 'fool around' with guys who are taken, Blaine."

Blaine was silent as he looked at the ground. "I just- I need to make this right, I need to talk to him…"

"Didn't you just see him? That was him; the guy who left wasn't it, why didn't you say anything then." Zoe looked at him confused and slightly frustrated.

Blaine sighed then quietly spoke, "That was his boyfriend with him." He looked up slowly, Sebastian looked very entertained, and Zoe looked concerned and worried.

"Oh- well then you've got some competition Anderson. His boyfriend was pretty hot if I do say so myself." Sebastian smirked at Blaine as he slid off the counter top.

Blaine crossed his arms looking away from his ex, "Shut up," he said with an annoyed tone to it.

Blaine only earned a laugh from Sebastian; "I've got to run," he stepped close to Blaine and leaned in so Zoe couldn't hear "You still owe me, Killer." Sebastian whispered as he then turned and walked out of the coffee shop, Blaine mentally kicking himself.