Four years had passed since Kurt and Blaine decided to have kids. They had put their names down at adoption agencies, had looked in to surrogacy and were about to give up. Jayden, who was now nine, was even starting to catch on that something was wrong. Kurt and Blaine were fighting every other day, and neither of them felt like they had the strength to deal with it anymore, and where starting to come to terms with the fact that maybe it was only meant to the three of them. This was until a unseasonably warm March morning. Kurt was sleeping when he heard his phone ring and answered it sleepily.

“Mr Hummel,” The unfamiliar voice began as Kurt sat up. “Have we called at a bad time?”

“No,” Kurt yawned. “Go ahead.”

“There is a woman in New York who would like to interview you and your husband about being a surrogate.” The man continued.

“Oh my god,” Kurt exclaimed. “When-when can we see her?”

This prompted Blaine to open his eyes, and watch as Kurt’s eyes became tear-filled and the taller man hung up the phone.

“What happened?” Blaine asked.

“There’s a woman who wants to be a surrogate for us.” Kurt exclaimed, as Blaine’s smile widened.

“Are you serious?” Blaine asked as Kurt nodded.

Their interview was on a Friday, and Kurt loved the woman, who they discovered, named Jess, from the moment he met her. She reminded him of a more toned down version of Santana.

“Jess,” Kurt said as the girl turned to him. “I know this is an odd question, but why do you want to be a surrogate?”

“I have a wife,” Jess said quietly. “We were in the same situation as you two were, trying to have kids, and when my wife did fall pregnant, I thought it would be good to help someone else out like we were helped out.”

“And it doesn’t matter that you’ll have a baby half related to you out there?” Blaine asked.

“No,” Jess smiled. “Because I know it will be in a good home, with parents who love it.”

From that second, Kurt and Blaine knew this was the woman. By the time everything was organised, it was June and Jess had successfully donated five eggs. Now all that was left before implantation was deciding who would get to fill the tube the doctor gave them with man gravy. Jayden had gone to bed, and Kurt was sitting up with Blaine who was holding the vile.

“Who should do this?” Blaine asked, tapping the vile.

“You,” Kurt said as Blaine just looked at him. “I have actually thought about this, and I want you to be the biological parent. I have Jayden, and I love him so much. But you deserve to have a child genetically related to you, and I will love her as much as you love Jayden.”

“Her?” Blaine asked, wiping away tears.

“I can’t see us with another boy Blaine.” Kurt laughed.

“I can,” Blaine commented. “Plus, if it is genetically related to me it’s going to be a boy. We actually haven’t had a biological girl on the Anderson side of the family for generations.”

A week later, Kurt and Blaine met Jess at the hospital for implantation. To say they were nervous was an understatement. It was another three weeks before they met Jess and her wife Laura, and a pregnancy test was taken. When Kurt and Blaine saw Laura, they remembered that she was going to have to be the one to put with the woman carrying their baby – and if Jess was anything like Rachel, it was going to be a ride.

“I don’t want to look,” Jess said placing the test on the sink. “It’s your baby anyway.”

“I’ll do it,” Kurt commented, before his eyes caught the pink plus sign. “Oh my god!”

“What?” Blaine asked impatiently, seeing a vacant expression on Kurt’s face. Not knowing if it was bad or good news.

“We’re going to be dads.” Kurt exclaimed as Blaine pulled him into a hug, and then Jess.