Sure, other people might think he was completely insane, but hey, now was the time to experiment right? Besides, he was being safe. Where was the harm in that?

Dinner made things phenomenally less awkward. Luke was surprisingly sweet and had a weakness for musical theater and was addicted to watching tennis, sheerly for the grunts the players let out each time they whacked their rackets at the ball.

Kurt had been painfully aware of Blaine’s presence at the restaurant and was honestly rather hurt that months after their Valentine’s conversation, Blaine still hadn’t made a move on him, but a week after Kurt suggests Blaine try dating, he was at some romantic little French restaurant with another guy.

Kurt was distracted from that line of though as Luke’s hand slipped into the one that wasn’t entwined with Cameron’s and the two other boys shared a knowing smile.

They assured him that it was going to be fine, they’ve done this before, and Cameron and Luke were casual sex partners before Cameron had started dating Kurt. Kurt was still a little nervous, unsure of how it was going to be not only to be the one doing the fucking for the first time, but to also be doing it while his boyfriend watched.

At first Kurt had found it incredibly distracting, not to mention just plain weird, to be kissing another guy in front of his boyfriend, but after his third wine cooler, Kurt’s defenses were slowly coming down and he found himself getting lost in the wet, velvet heat of Luke’s mouth.

The two of them had long since collapsed on Luke’s king-sized four-poster bed and Luke was on top of Kurt, legs on either side of Kurt’s thighs. Kurt rolled his hips up into the other boy earning a delicious moan.

Kurt’s hands explored the other boy’s almost completely naked body. One hand glided over Luke’s smooth skin, the other slipping into his boxers to clutch at his sinfully round ass. Luke moaned into the heated kiss and Kurt was tired of taking it slow. He flipped Luke over, taking control and grinding his hips down into the other boy, hard.

After a few more minutes of the delicious friction Kurt pulled away, sliding down Luke’s body to pull off the boy’s boxers.

A low grunt of approval sounded to Kurt’s left and Kurt tilted his head to catch Cameron’s eye. Cameron had stripped naked and was stroking his leaking cock with near brutal force, a force only sped up as Kurt leaned down and sucked Luke’s erection into his mouth. Luke and Cameron let out near identical moans and Kurt smiled around the cock in his mouth.

Luke thrust a well-used bottle of lube at Kurt and he took the hint, slathering his fingers with it and lowering his hand to Luke’s entrance.

The first finger slipped in surprisingly easy, though his hole was tight as ever living fuck. Kurt wondered momentarily if his own ass was this tight.

Luke groaned loudly. “More, please, more,” he whined.

Kurt was only too happy to oblige. He pressed another finger at Luke’s entrance, this one met a bit more resistance, but slowly made it’s way deep into Luke’s ass. Kurt tried to remember everything that Cameron did to prepare him, so he scissored his fingers experimentally, drawing a mewling sob of pleasure from Luke.

He curled his fingers up, moving them around until Luke threw his head back with a shuddering moan. Kurt grinned at having found Luke’s pleasure point and rubbed over it for a few seconds until Luke was moaning incoherently, a feeble ‘please’ escaping his wet lips every few seconds.

Kurt pressed in a third finger slowly, pumping his fingers in and out a little bit at a time until Luke was pressing back, fucking himself on Kurt’s hand, and oh god that was hot.

“Kurt,” Luke moaned, “I need you. Get in me. Now.” He shoved a condom at Kurt and Kurt nearly tore it apart in his attempt to get it out and on his cock. Now.

Once Kurt was rubbered up, he positioned himself at Luke’s entrance and pushed. Oh my god. The head of his cock pressed in and Kurt thought he was going to die—Luke was so tight and ugh it felt so fucking good and he was barely even in yet.

Cameron’s sideline moans reached a fever pitch as Kurt slowly pumped all the way into Luke. Luke, for his part, was moaning like a Tijuana whore, wrapping his legs around Kurt’s waist, pulling him in closer, and it took all of Kurt’s self-control as his dick was fully enveloped by Luke’s tight ass.

Kurt gave his hips an experimental roll and rumbled a low groan bubbled out of him. He pulled out almost completely and snapped his hips forward instinctively.

Luke was panting and babbling incoherently as Kurt continued his ministrations, fucking into Luke with hard, deep thrusts.

The bed dipped next to the two boys as Cameron crawled up next to them. Cam’s cock was an angry, purpling red and he practically begged Kurt to wrap his had around it as he pulled Kurt into a sloppy kiss.

Kurt’s wrist moved in time with his hips as his mouth worked his boyfriend while his dick fucked another guy and a few moments later, Cameron came with a shuddering orgasm all over Kurt’s stomach, and splattering across Luke’s legs and crotch.

Cameron collapsed on the bed next to Luke, basking in his post-orgasmic afterglow. Kurt watched, fascinated as Cameron’s hand slid over Luke’s stomach, playing with the treasure trail that lead to Luke’s leaking erection. Cameron’s hand wrapped itself around Luke’s cock, and Luke’s hips jerked up into the touch, his head rolling to the side, eyes meeting Cameron’s.

For a few moments the two boys just stared at each other, Luke letting out a few whiny moans, before Cameron lurched forward, capturing Luke’s lips in a heated kiss. The kiss started slow and hot, the passion building up to a heated frenzy of lips and tongues and teeth.

Cameron, Kurt realized, had never kissed him like that—with so much passion, yet still tender and oh so sweet. Cameron was in love with Luke, and from the way Luke was moaning into Cameron’s touches, he was just as in love with Cameron.

Strange, Kurt thought as his hips snapped into Luke again, his orgasm just moments away, he wasn’t even jealous that his boyfriend was in love with someone else. In fact, the two of them together, was phenomenally hot, and it was with that thought that Kurt came hard.

As Kurt rode out his orgasm, Cameron managed to rip Luke’s from his and the three boys collapsed on the bed, sweaty, sated, and covered in semen. Kurt breathed shakily for a few minutes, staring at the ceiling and trying to regain his bearings, but as he turned to look at the two other boys he realized that their mouths had still yet to detach. Cameron was already hard again and Luke’s hand had snaked down to milk the erection with slow, firm pumps.

Kurt was transfixed as he watched his boyfriend make out with Luke. It was like porn, but better because it was right there, and Kurt could reach out and touch, but he somehow felt that this was something he shouldn’t interrupt, so he kept still and just watched as Cameron slid on top of Luke, pressing him hard into the mattress.

Cameron’s kisses turned biting as he sucked and kissed his way down Luke’s neck and across his collarbone. Cameron’s hips ground into Luke, Luke’s now half-hard erection stiffening at the friction.

Only a few minutes passed before Luke was begging Cameron to get inside them and was thrusting another condom at Cameron. Cameron expertly rolled the condom on, wasting no time in positioning himself at Luke’s still stretched entrance, and pushing in.

He didn’t give Luke much time to adjust, quickly moving from gentle thrusts to a very hard, very thorough fucking.

Kurt hadn’t even noticed that he had instinctively pulled the condom off his own dick and his hand was now pumping his own erection. I’m insane, the thought flitted across Kurt’s mind as he realized he was not only getting turned on by watching his boyfriend fuck another guy, but he was getting off on it.

Cameron’s hands gripped Luke’s hips with a bruising force as he rammed into him. Luke had his head tipped back, eyes closed, and moan open in a constant stream of half-screaming moans. Luke came first, his orgasm hitting him like a ton of bricks, Cameron closely followed screaming Luke’s name, and Kurt quickly followed the pair, his cum spurting across his stomach and chest.

Cameron and Luke had seemingly completely forgotten about Kurt’s existence, as instead of collapsing next to each other post-orgasm, Cameron stayed deep inside Luke, their mouths tangled in a slow, sweet kiss.

Kurt cleared his throat, and that pulled the two boys out of their oblivion, both snapping their heads to face Kurt. Cameron seemed to realize it first, and quickly pulled back from Luke, extracting himself from the boy’s embrace.

“Oh my god, I’m so sorry,” Cameron began, “I—we, just got so caught up in the moment, I wasn’t even thinking.”

Kurt held up a hand to stop Cameron from continuing, and Cam and Luke stopped breathing, not sure of what Kurt was going to say. All three boys sat up on the bed, none of them touching each other.

“It’s okay.” Kurt almost couldn’t believe what he was about to do.

“What?” The other two asked simultaneously. Kurt glanced between them and met Cam’s eyes.

“You two are obviously in love with each other,” Kurt blurted out, Cameron couldn’t meet anyone’s eyes and Luke blushed to the roots of his hair.

“I-I can explain,” Cam stuttered. Hurt flashed across Luke’s face, already expecting a rejection.

“Cam,” Kurt started, Cameron snapped his head up to look at him. “It’s okay. You two can be together, I’ll be okay.”

Neither Cameron nor Luke seemed to understand what Kurt had said for a few moments.

“I don’t want to get between two people in love,” Kurt added.

Cameron kissed Kurt hard on the mouth briefly.

“Thank you!” Cameron turned to Luke, terrified. “Well, I mean, I don’t want to assume that you want to be with me, but do you?”

Luke laughed and pulled Cameron into a deep kiss and Kurt watched, the pain he felt not from breaking off his relationship, but in realizing that he might never get to have that. That sheer love and adoration with which the two boys attached themselves to each other.

Kurt slid off the bed and started pulling his clothes on. Luke pulled back from kissing Cameron.

“Thank you, Kurt. Thank you for saying what we’ve been too afraid to say,” Luke smiled. “I’m sorry though, I guess I kind of stole your boyfriend.”

Kurt laughed this time.

“I think it was I who just had him on loan until he saw the light,” Kurt replied. He and Luke shared an understanding smile.

Luke and Cameron shared a loving look, before Luke turned back to Kurt.

“Say, I don’t know if this is too soon for you, but I had kind of been dating this other guy and I’m supposed to be going on a date with him tomorrow night, if you’d I don’t know, like me to set you up with him.”

Kurt was taken aback at the proposal, but contemplated it a moment.

“I’d like that,” Kurt said with a smile. If I can’t be with the one I love, Kurt thought sadly, I might as well try to find someone else to be with.