Kurt arrived at Blaine's only to find two police cruisers outside. He felt his heart stop as he ran up to the door. Blaine barely opened the door before he collapsed in his boyfriend's arms. "Someone took her. Someone saw get abducted. I should have turned the car around and got her. It's all my fault."

Kurt was still in shock. He snapped to and wrapped his arms around the crumbling boy. He rubbed his hands softly over Blaine's back. "Blaine, you know that's not true. Come on, let's go inside."

"No. The police are in there. I can't deal with the police again this year. Can we just get Anna and go somewhere. Please." Kurt looked at Blaine's face. He had to admit that Blaine was right; they had had too many interactions with the police and tragedy. Blaine went and got permission to take Anna out for fresh air, and then the three were off.

"Where do you want to go?" Kurt asked quietly.

"I think you know where I want to go." Blaine stared down at his lap. Kurt gave a small nod and started driving. After 40 minutes of driving, Kurt pulled into the cemetery. In silence, they walked to Claire Anderson's tombstone. They stood there for a moment before Blaine fell to the ground in tears. He curls up in to the fetal position gripping at the grass below him. "Mommy, please, please let her be ok. I can't lose her, I can't lose her too."

Kurt felt his heart break as he watched Blaine fall apart. Anna buried her face into Kurt's arm. She still hasn't said a single word. Something that is extremely uncharacteristic for her. Kurt looked between the two of them. He squeeze his eyes shut and did something he never thought he would. He found himself praying. Not to anyone in particular, but praying. Katie had to come back, she had to be safe. Anna and Blaine deserved that much.

0000000000000

It was almost midnight when they returned to the house. Blaine had been texting their Nana non-stop the whole time. Mostly it was to inform of their location, but secretly to find out if Katie was found. Kurt was about to say goodnight, when Anna attached herself to his side again. She looked up at him with pleading eyes. He didn't have the strength or heart to pull her off. He called his dad and told him what was going on. Burt gave him permission to stay over and to miss school the next day.

Once inside, Anna dragged Kurt into her room and Blaine followed. They all stayed in there that night. Blaine barely slept, he tossed and turned, he cried, he pleaded with any entity listening to help find Katie. Kurt didn't sleep either. He was too busy watching over Blaine and Anna. Anna did sleep, but she was no longer silent. She cried and called out in her sleep. Kurt would go and sit on the bed, rubbing soothing circles on her back.

Jo-Ann, or Nana as she preferred, was too busy siting in the family room, staring at the door, to sleep. The whole house was on edge.

0000000000

Kurt opened his eyes at 3 in the afternoon. Blaine was still asleep next to him on the floor. Anna was awake, sitting on her bed, staring at a frame in her hands. "Hey Anna Bear. Whats that?" She turned the frame towards him. It was a picture of all of them in New Oreleans that summer. Kurt loved every second of that trip, well except the creeper who hit on him and the huge fight he had with Blaine. That was the trip that Blaine told him he planned to marry Kurt one day and have a family. And now here they sat, an already broken family that was falling even more apart. "Anna? Will you please talk to me?" she shook her head. "Please. It's only me, Kurtsie." She shook her head again. "Anna, please, I need to hear your voice. Will you please sing with me? Please." Kurt was in tears. He had to try.

The other night dear, as I lay sleeping

I dreamed I held you in my arms

But when I awoke, dear, I was mistaken

So I hung my head and I cried.

You are my sunshine, my only sunshine

You make me happy when skies are gray

You'll never know dear, how much I love you

Please don't take my sunshine away

Kurt looked at her, pleading. Anna broke down and sang.

You are my sunshine, my only sunshine

You make me happy when skies are gray

You'll never know dear, how much I love you

Please don't take my sunshine away

Blaine awoke to her Kurt and Anna singing. Fresh tears ran down his face when he heard the lyrics.

You are my sunshine, my only sunshine

You make me happy when skies are gray

You'll never know dear, how much I love you

Please don't take my sunshine away

The three of them hugged and fell in to silence. After a long pause, they heard the phone downstairs ring. As calmly as possible, they headed downstairs. Nana was holding the phone with trembling fingers. She saw Blaine, "It's for you." He took the receiver from her and grabbed Kurt's hand with his free one.

"Hey, little fag! I hear you're looking for something." The voice on the line was odd, someone obviously was using a voice changer from the joke shop.

"Who is this?" Blaine felt sick all over again as he heard a scream in the background.

"How about instead, you tell your slut of a sister to shut the fuck up!"

Another scream came from the other side of the line. It sounded like a 'help'. Blaine jumped when he heard the smack that followed. "Just leave her alone. If you have an issue with me, then take it out on me. Not her."

Blaine was about to hang up when Nana, encouraged him to keep going. She whispered in his ear about how the police was tracing calls to their house and he had to keep the call going.

"Just bring my sister home ok man."

"Not until, I'm done with her. There are plenty more things that her tight little body needs."

Blaine was going to throw up. Nana's cell phone beeped. It was an officer informing them that the found the source of the call and cops were on the way. Nana signaled to Blaine to hang up. "You lay one finger on her and I will kill you, you got that!" Blaine slammed the phone down, he ran into the bathroom, and threw up.

00000000

Two hours later found them all siting in the Lima Police Station. Blaine and Kurt chewed nervously at their nails and Anna had fallen silent once more. Suddenly, Katie came bursting through the doors. She ran to Blaine, holding him tight. "Blaine, I am so, so, sorry. I never should have gotten mad and ran off like that! It's all my fault, I'm so stupid!"

"No, it's my fault. I shouldn't have said those things and I should have gone after you. I am the worst brother ever! If something bad happened to you, i… I just… I don't know." They cried against each other for 10 minutes. A female officer then came over and informed Katie that she needed to get checked out by a doctor, in case she had received any injuries during the abduction. When she stood was the first time anyone really got a look at her. She was still in her Cheerios uniform but it was torn and dirty, her arms and legs were covered in small cuts and bruises, and her hair was messy and knotted. Blaine was starting to feel sick again and Kurt and Nana were in devastation. The moment was interrupted when little Anna spoke up.

"wow Katie, you look like shit!" Katie reached down and gave Anna the biggest hug.

"I love you Anna Banana. You're my rock." And off she went to the station's physician.

00000000

"Alright, one last time. So I was waiting for Puck to pick me up at the school, when this van came out of nowhere. There were three big guys in cheesy Halloween masks. Two of them grabbed me and put me in the van. I kicked and screamed to get free, but they got me good. They took me to the pier and I thought they were gonna throw me in or something. I was dragged to this warehouse and tied to the pipes. The idiots didn't tie up my legs so every time one of them tried to touch me, I kicked like crazy. They stole my phone and called Blaine from it. I screamed so he would hear that I was still alive. The biggest guy hung up and started toward me. The other two held my legs still. That's when they heard the sirens and took off, leaving me there. I still don't know who they were. The police said they were locals and I was just taken at random. I assumed they figured out about Blaine going through my phone. It's filled with family pictures. But yea, then the cops took me to the station and I walked away with only a bruised rib and dislocated elbow. Unfortunately I'll have to sideline for the next month for Cheerios, but at least I'm ok." Katie looked up to see Justin staring at her with tears in his eyes.

"Katie, I…. I should have been there." He was surprised to see her in school after only two weeks, her abduction was hot news, and even more surprised when she sat with him at lunch instead of the Cheerios.

"Justin, I'm sorry. I thought that if I was single, like Santana and some of the other Cheerios, I'd be as popular as them. I don't know why I care about being popular, but I do. I don't care if you're a jock or not; Blaine told me you joined Glee. I like you. I like being with you. Please take me back."

"Hells yea, Honeybear!" he scooted closer to her. He wrapped his arm around her waist, careful of her still healing injuries. They sighed simultaneously. This is right.

Blaine watched carefully from the other end of the long table, smiling slightly when they cuddled against each other. Kurt placed a hand on his shoulder. "If I didn't know any better, Blaine, I'd say you learned to like Justin and Katie together."

"Nonsense Kurt, I just like that even with the Glee bonding, he is still terrified of me." He gave Kurt a wink. Kurt leaned his head on Blaine's shoulder. Somehow, he knew that things could only get better. "Oh and babe, Puck delivered on those fake IDs for this weekend. I am finally getting your sexy ass to a gay bar."

Yep, Kurt thought with a groan, it's can't get better than this.